Adam Chilton (Chicago), Jonathan S. Masur (Chicago) & Kyle Rozema (Washington U.), Rethinking Law School Tenure Standards, 50 J. Authorized Stud. 1 (2021):
We research the implications of stricter tenure requirements in legislation colleges, an setting wherein 95 % of all tenure-track hires obtain tenure. To take action, we assemble a novel information set of the articles and quotation counts of 1,712 legislation professors who have been granted tenure at top-100 legislation colleges between 1970 and 2007. We first present that pretenure analysis data are extremely predictive of future educational impression. We then simulate the results of making use of stricter tenure requirements utilizing predictions of legislation professors’ future educational impression on the time of their tenure selections. We discover that growing tenure denial charges to the identical degree as hard-science departments—which might require growing denial charges by 30 share factors—may greater than double the median posttenure educational impression of the college that legislation colleges initially tenure.
Brian Leiter (Chicago), Deny Tenure More Often, Raise Scholarly Impact:
I believe their primary level is right: legislation colleges, particularly these sustaining a excessive scholarly profile, ought to be extra demanding about tenure.