Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage Highlights The Young Sheldon Spinoff’s Missy Problem

Warning: This article contains SPOILERS for Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage episode 2.

While Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage managed to incorporate Georgie’s little sister Missy as early as its second episode, this outing did prove that bringing back Young Sheldon’s heroine brought up some plot problems. Young Sheldon’s spinoff Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage was left in a tricky position by its two predecessors. Young Sheldon’s finale ended with Sheldon’s older brother Georgie and his wife Mandy happily married. The Big Bang Theory season 11, episode 23, “The Sibling Realignment,” revealed that Georgie was divorced years later. Clearly, something went wrong in between, and Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage needed to explain what.

The first episode of Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage outlined the couple’s struggles finding a home of their own, but living with Mandy’s parents also wasn’t a stress-free alternative. Georgie was thankful for the job that Jim McAllister provided him at his tire store, but he was also frustrated by his critical mother-in-law Audrey. Mandy wanted to return to work to regain her independence but found herself struggling to find a suitable job in an unaccommodating marketplace. Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage season 1, episode 2, “Some New York Nonsense,” built on these plots and brought back a familiar face from Young Sheldon.

Missy’s First Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage Appearance Was Frustrating

Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage Struggled To Incorporate Missy

In “Some New York Nonsense,” Georgie found himself overwhelmed by the stress of handling his young baby, his marriage, his grief over losing his father, life in the McAllister family home, and his job at the tire store. This was further exacerbated when the episode brought back Young Sheldon’s Missy and proved she was more rebellious than ever before. Missy was suspended for pulling the fire alarm to get out of class, and she swore Georgie to secrecy about the incident, since they both knew how their mother Mary would react. This storyline was an intriguing, but also frustrating, addition.

Missy had sufficient screen time to bring up her problems, such as unprocessed grief, school struggles, teenage rebellion, and even missing Sheldon. However, there was little space for her to properly explore them as “Some New York Nonsense” mostly focused on the titular issue, namely Georgie’s anxiety. Georgie eventually suffered a panic attack thanks to adding his sister’s secret to his pile of stresses, but he dismissed the idea of anxiety as mere metropolitan doublespeak. Like Georgie’s struggles with Audrey, his anxiety soon became just another issue that the show’s main character buried deep down inside, hoping it would disappear.

Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage Separating Missy’s Appearance From Mary & Meemaw Is Correct

Keeping The Cooper Family’s Cameo Appearances Separate Was Clever

It was undeniably moving and unexpectedly sad to see Georgie struggle with anxiety, and the scenes where he sought counsel at the grave of George Sr. were among the strongest of the episode. However, it was still unfortunate that, in focusing on how his sister’s issues impacted Georgie, Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage struggled to foreground Missy’s story. This was never more obvious than when Mandy spoke with Missy on the phone, searching for a missing Georgie and hoping he was visiting his family’s home. When Missy said she hadn’t seen her brother, Mandy politely asked how she was holding up.

Missy’s story was secondary to her impact on Georgie’s life.

Missy began to open up emotionally, only to be shut down when Mandy hurriedly hung up on her because Georgie had returned home. The moment proved just how much Missy’s story was secondary to her impact on Georgie’s life, and this underlined the value of separating her comeback from the return of Mary and Meemaw in the pilot episode. Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage would definitely feel like a direct continuation of Young Sheldon if these characters returned together and, even with a laugh track added to its setup, the spinoff would seem more like a sequel series without keeping the family separate.

Missy’s Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage’s Return Sets A Problematic Future For Georgie

Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage Episode 2 Set Up Future Worries For Georgie

As “Some New York Nonsense” prioritized Georgie’s anxiety over Missy’s struggles, the episode proved how much the show’s title characters will dominate its action. However, this doesn’t mean that Missy won’t play a major role in Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage. Before Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage began, Missy was already portrayed as a rebellious teen throughout Young Sheldon seasons 6 and 7. Missy will continue to act out, meaning “Some New York Nonsense” could expand on this storyline in her subsequent appearances. The episode sets up a potential pattern wherein Missy will only appear when she is in trouble or needs help.

This will be rough for Georgie as it will most likely exacerbate his existing anxiety. After all, none of the other causes of the condition, from living with the McAllisters to his grief to Mandy’s unemployment, seem likely to be relieved any time soon. While the Young Sheldon spinoff’s upcoming Thanksgiving episode might be an exception to this rule, as it will be a family affair involving all the Coopers, Missy’s teenage rebellion could drive a wedge between her and her brother in future episodes. This could help justify Georgie’s resentment of Sheldon in The Big Bang Theory.

How Can Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage Solve Its Big Missy Challenge

Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage Episode 2 Sets Up A Solution

However, while this might align with the backstory mentioned in the earlier show, it is still a bleak trajectory for Georgie and Missy’s sibling relationship. Knowing that the titular union in Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage is doomed makes the prospect of Georgie also growing distant from his younger sister even sadder. Fortunately, there may be a solution to this issue. Conversations with George Sr. may help Young Sheldon’s spinoff if Georgie finds more solace and support in the memory of his father. Visiting George Sr.’s grave may not have been what Missy needed, but it might help Georgie cope.

Georgie must be more than a mere problem solver for his sister and the maturity to change in this dynamic must come from him.

The episode’s scenes at the graveside were its strongest moments, which could help future storylines involving Missy and Georgie. Before bringing back Young Sheldon characters in Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage , the show needs to find a way to fix the relationship between Georgie and Missy. Georgie must be more than a mere problem solver for his sister and, thanks to her youth, the maturity to change in this dynamic must come from him. Luckily, visiting George Sr’s grave and continuing his heart-to-heart conversations could help the hero of Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage overcome the trauma he suffered in Young Sheldon’s ending.

New episodes of
Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage
air on CBS Thursdays at 8pm.